No Money, No Cards, No Gift Cards
Please note: There are exceptions to every rule. These are my own personal rules I use to get gifts, and may not apply for everyone in all situations.
No Money
I grew up with the notion that money was the gift you gave when you couldn't think of anything else, or couldn't be bothered to actually go out and get a gift. I have talked to many people through the years who have said that getting money as a gift is akin to being assigned a value. It feels as if the person giving the money is saying, "I will give this person $20, because that is all they are worth to me and/or it's the smallest amount of change I have".
If money is your gift of choice, here is one way that I have seen it work well:
In high school one of my friends once gave money in a rolled up banner. She created the banner out of construction paper and on it was written "Happy Birthday". Rubber cemented over the letters were dollar bills. The number of dollar bills corresponded to the age the birthday person was turning. Every time the birthday person picked off a dollar a little bit more of the message was reveled.
Some exceptions to this rule are:
- If you are that uncle who only ever sees their niece(s) or nephew(s) maybe once every year and really has no idea what they are interested in. Note that this exception is not just for uncles, but anyone who is obligated, or chooses, to give a gift to a recipient you may not know as well as you should to buy a truly heartfelt gift. This is one of the times where money is a good gift because it can allow you to go out and choose something with your gift recipient, bringing you closer together. By doing so you can subtlety acknowledge the fact that you may not know the person that well, but still wanted to give them something, and not have to feel gift rejection if you bought something that ended off being totally off the mark.
- The person you are getting the gift for is the type of person who actually would appreciate money more than a handpicked gift (or asked for money instead). Know who it is you are getting your gift for.
No Cards
A card is not a gift. A card is something that goes with a gift to express a sentiment or anecdote relating to the event. Before I explain how I use cards with gifts, please be aware that the cards that you attach to gifts and holiday greeting cards are two separate types of cards. If you are holiday card enthusiast, rest assured that I am not being totally anti-card here.
The way I use cards is this: I only attach a card with a gift if the recipient of my gift is farther than driving distance. I use cards to explain my gift, or talk about it in a way that I might have done had I been there to witness my recipient opening my gift. However, the card itself is never a gift. If I am present for the gift opening I see a card as superfluous and redundant to my presence.
Later in my blog, I will be interviewing a close friend of the family who hand makes her own cards. I will be asking her how she makes them, why, and her general thoughts on them.
Here is my recap, because I cannot stress this enough: A card is not a gift. A card is what accompanies a gift. If you want an easy way out in gift giving and decide to buy the person a card instead of a gift, don't.
No Gift Cards
This is the one rule that I absolutely will not break. Ever. If money is bad, then gift cards are worse because it shows that the person actually went out to buy the card (or picked it up on their way somewhere) but couldn't be bothered to browse the rest of the store for something in it you might like. To add insult to injury, a gift card is for a specific location, and a set amount. I know countless people who carry around tons of gift cards only containing a few cents on them. Because of this, gift cards become annoying. And you don't want to give an annoying gift.The only time I have ever heard of a well gifted gift card was from a friend of the family. He was telling us that his daughter was having a rough time where she lived, and so he had ordered and sent her a gift card for a restaurant that the family went to whenever they visited, which also happened to be her favorite.
I have been divorced twice, and I'm engaged for the third time. Some say, third's a charm or third time a strike. In my case, my fiance is my heart and soul. We were childhood best friend since 1981. But, I was 3 years older than him and our mothers weren't friends anymore. I moved on, but he didn't. I was not aware he was in love with me all these years until we met again when he found me in 2008. Most people who had childhood crush would get over it as they get older. What I have is very rare, and I don't think I will ever find anyone else who loved me for me and my faults. My marriage was falling apart, and I was becoming anorexic the same year my fiance found me. If it weren't for him, I wouldn't be in a good shape. I was trying hard to hang in there for the sake of my 4 kids.
ReplyDeleteMy story is a greatest gift of all. Gifts do not necessarily have to cost money. They could be handmade or by using gestures. Either way, if it comes from the heart, gifts would be the most valuable to those who received them. Tell me what do you think. I'd like to know something you might know more about.
Dear Ariana,
ReplyDeleteI have to disagree with your last rule; I love gift cards, so long as they are for places I frequent very often. My cousins all live in Texas and I used to live in Louisiana, and I could always rely on at least three gift cards every year for my birthday, usually all to the same place. They would always ask me what I wanted for a present, and I would always give them a list of stores I frequent. Likewise, when a friend of mine was starting out in college and had just gotten a Nook from her parents, we accompanied the gift with a Barnes and Noble gift card to get her collection started.
Maybe on their own gift cards are thoughtless, but I believe that in certain situations they can be presented rather well.
--Lorraine Bett